[{"data":1,"prerenderedAt":71},["ShallowReactive",2],{"q-house-105-1-civil-law-014":3},{"subject":4,"subjectSlug":5,"subjectKicker":6,"subjectShort":7,"subjectMcqNote":8,"question":9,"related":25,"sameNumber":50,"hasEssay":24},"民法概要","civil-law","民法概要 · Civil Law","民法","105–106 年 40 題(每題 1.25 分)、107 年起 25 題(每題 2 分)",{"id":10,"webId":11,"year":12,"session":13,"subject":4,"number":14,"stem":15,"options":16,"answer":21,"answerNote":22,"lawYear":12,"explanation":23,"freq":13,"indexable":24},"house-105-1-民法概要-014","house-105-1-civil-law-014",105,1,14,"甲欲向乙租屋 3 年，雙方僅用通訊軟體 Line 互相協商，乙已於對話中允諾，但後來丙出更高租金，於是乙改將該屋出租給丙並交付之，後來丙得乙之同意將該屋再出租給丁，某日丁因大意未關爐火將該屋燒毀，下列敘述何者正確？",{"A":17,"B":18,"C":19,"D":20},"乙可以向丁主張侵權行為責任","甲可主張乙丙之租賃契約未以書面簽訂，因此無效","丙可以向丁主張侵權行為責任","甲可以向丙主張有優先締約權，因此乙丙之租賃契約對甲係屬無效","A",null,"本題考點：不動產租賃未立字據的效果，以及所有權人對毀損其物之人主張侵權行為的請求權基礎。\n【正解理由】乙為該屋所有權人，丁因大意未關爐火而將屋燒毀，屬有過失且不法地侵害他人之權利。依《民法》第 184 條第一項前段，因故意或過失，不法侵害他人之權利者，負損害賠償責任，乙的所有權既遭侵害，自得對丁請求損害賠償，故選 A。\n【逐項排除】\n(A) 房屋所有權是《民法》第 184 條第一項前段所稱之「權利」，丁有過失、行為不法且與損害有因果關係，侵權行為成立，本項正確。\n(B) 依《民法》第 422 條，不動產之租賃契約期限逾一年者未以字據訂立，視為不定期限之租賃而非無效；且甲並非乙丙契約的當事人，無從主張該契約的效力。\n(C) 丙為承租人，對該屋享有的是租賃債權而非所有權；丁係經乙同意的次承租人，依《民法》第 444 條第二項，因次承租人應負責之事由所生之損害，由承租人丙對出租人負賠償責任，丙與丁之間應循租賃契約的權利義務處理。\n(D) 縱乙先前在對話中已允諾出租於甲，甲取得的也只是債權上的請求權，債權不具排他效力，無從使乙丙間已成立並交付的租賃契約歸於無效。\n【記憶點】燒掉的是誰的所有權，侵權行為的請求權就歸誰。",true,[26,30,34,38,42,46],{"webId":27,"stem":28,"number":29,"year":12,"session":13},"house-105-1-civil-law-013","有關不當得利所應返還之客體，下列何者錯誤？",13,{"webId":31,"stem":32,"number":33,"year":12,"session":13},"house-105-1-civil-law-015","依侵權行為請求損害賠償之說明，下列敘述何者正確？",15,{"webId":35,"stem":36,"number":37,"year":12,"session":13},"house-105-1-civil-law-012","依現行民法規定，有關違反法定要式規定之法律行為效力，下列何者應為無效？",12,{"webId":39,"stem":40,"number":41,"year":12,"session":13},"house-105-1-civil-law-016","有關民法第 250 條規定之違約金類型有「損害賠償總額預定違約金」與「懲罰性違約金」兩種，下列敘述何者正確？",16,{"webId":43,"stem":44,"number":45,"year":12,"session":13},"house-105-1-civil-law-011","有關契約之敘述，下列何者正確？",11,{"webId":47,"stem":48,"number":49,"year":12,"session":13},"house-105-1-civil-law-017","若買賣標的物為特定物時，買受人不得請求下列那一種物的瑕疵擔保之法定效果？",17,[51,55,59,63,67],{"webId":52,"year":53,"stem":54,"number":14},"house-114-1-civil-law-014",114,"甲、乙兩人合夥開了一家小麵館 M，生意興隆。下列何者錯誤？",{"webId":56,"year":57,"stem":58,"number":14},"house-113-1-civil-law-014",113,"甲乙丙丁分別共有 A 地，甲以乙丙丁為被告提起分割共有物之訴，獲得勝訴確定判決。下列敘述，何者正確？",{"webId":60,"year":61,"stem":62,"number":14},"house-112-1-civil-law-014",112,"民法關於死亡宣告的規定，下列何者正確？",{"webId":64,"year":65,"stem":66,"number":14},"house-111-1-civil-law-014",111,"關於共有不動產分管契約之敘述，下列何者正確？",{"webId":68,"year":69,"stem":70,"number":14},"house-110-1-civil-law-014",110,"關於合夥的敘述，下列何者正確？",1786689128378]